Jay Feely built a 17 year career as an NFL placekicker, playing for multiple franchises while becoming known for clutch performances and game winning kicks. He is frequently recognized for his tenure with the Atlanta Falcons and New York Giants, yet his journey spanned several teams across the league.
Below is a structured overview of his team history, highlighting key seasons, roles, and performance metrics that defined his professional journey.
| Team | Years | Key Role | Notable Achievements |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arizona Cardinals | 1998–2001 | Starting Kicker | Set franchise records for single-season field goals (22 in 2000) |
| Atlanta Falcons | 2002–2008 | Primary Kicker | Made Pro Bowl in 2004, led NFC in scoring (2004) |
| New York Giants | 2009–2011 | Starting Kicker | Won Super Bowl XLVI, made game-winning kick in 2011 playoffs |
| Denver Broncos | 2012 | Veteran Presence | Provided playoff experience during run to Super Bowl 50 |
| Indianapolis Colts | 2013 | Backup Kicker | Served as reliable backup and situational specialist |
Arizona Cardinals tenure and performance
Feely joined the Arizona Cardinals as a free agent and became the team's primary kicker, earning a reputation for reliability in the desert. During his four year stretch in Arizona, he handled both regular season and preseason responsibilities with consistent accuracy.
His time in Arizona included multiple 40 plus point seasons and several memorable fourth quarter drives that helped keep games competitive. Cardinals fans remember his composure in high pressure moments and his willingness to match practice standards with in game execution.
Atlanta Falcons leadership and Pro Bowl season
Moving to Atlanta marked a career high point for Feely, where he became the face of the kicking game and a staple of the Falcons offense. The 2004 season stands out as his most decorated year, highlighted by a Pro Bowl selection and league leading scoring totals.
As the Falcons chased playoff victories, he regularly handled kickoffs and extra points, contributing to special teams units that ranked among the league's best during that span. His preparation routines and film study habits set a standard for younger kickers joining the franchise.
New York Giants legacy and Super Bowl victory
In New York, Feely embraced the role of clutch kicker, delivering critical scores during a playoff run that culminated in a Super Bowl title. His presence on the field was felt during dramatic moments when the Giants needed points to protect narrow leads.
The 2011 season showcased his ability to perform in hostile environments, combining technical precision with mental resilience. Giants supporters point to his contributions as essential elements of the team's broader success on defense and special teams.
Later career with Broncos and Colts
Even in the later stages of his career, Feely remained a valued contributor, providing veteran leadership and reliable execution for depth-challenged teams. Short term stints with Denver and Indianapolis allowed him to share insights from decades of game experience while maintaining professional standards.
These final seasons emphasized his adaptability, as he adjusted to new coaching schemes and supported younger colleagues who looked to him for guidance during crucial points of games.
Final perspective on Jay Feely's NFL journey
- Played for the Arizona Cardinals, Atlanta Falcons, New York Giants, Denver Broncos, and Indianapolis Colts
- Spent the most seasons with the Atlanta Falcons, where he achieved a Pro Bowl selection
- Won a Super Bowl ring with the New York Giants in the 2011 season
- Known for clutch performances and consistent kicking under pressure
- Left a legacy of professionalism and preparation across multiple teams
FAQ
Reader questions
Which team did Jay Feely play for the longest?
Arizona Cardinals from 1998 to 2001, followed by the Atlanta Falcons from 2002 to 2008, making the Falcons his longest tenure.
Did Jay Feely ever make a playoff winning kick for the Giants?
Yes, he made a memorable game winning field goal during the 2011 playoffs that helped secure a victory on the road.
Which team won a Super Bowl while Jay Feely was on their roster?
He earned a Super Bowl ring with the New York Giants after the 2011 season.
What was Jay Feely's most productive scoring season?
His most productive season came in 2004 with the Atlanta Falcons, when he led the NFC in scoring and was selected to the Pro Bowl.